The C in USB C stands for Confusion

The industry is slowly moving to the USB C connector, while this might sound like just an incremental change, yet another standard, I think this has the potential to change many things, but also to confuse users a lot.

The USB C connector has the following features:

  • Symmetrical: USB-C cables have the same connector at both ends
  • Alternate Mode: the USB-C connector can carry USB signals, but also other protocols like , , and MHL.
  • High power delivery, up to 60W which is enough to charge a laptop.
  • Reversible, no longer will you have to flip the connector five times until you got it right

How standards proliferate – situation there are 14 competing standards – ridiculous we need to develop one universal standard that covers everyone's use cases. Yeah!  Soon 
situation there are 15 competing standards.

These features mean that a laptop can just have one type of port, and the same port can be used to charge it, connect it to a screen or to a hub where keyboard and mouse will be connected. The fact that there is the same connector at both ends means that you can use the same cables for everything. This is cool. Of course this means yet another type of cable and connector, this is less cool.

Things get confusing when you consider power delivery. Up until now, USB cables had a direction, when you connected a device to another one, power went from the A connector (the flat one which everyone plugs the wrong way) to the other one – this is consistent with the way main power plugs work. With USB-C, what happens when you connect your phone to your laptop? When you connect your laptop to your screen? The behaviour will be software defined, which means bugs, confusing interfaces.

Alternate mode can also make things confusing, up until now when you connected a device into a USB port, it was a USB device, with a USB driver. Let’s consider a screen with an ethernet connector connected to a laptop using a USB-C cable. It could be the following:

  • A USB hub with two devices, for instance a DisplayLink screen and a USB ethernet adapter.
  • A HDMI device, with the ethernet port run using HEC (HDMI Ethernet Channel).
  • A DisplayPort device, with the ethernet port implemented on top of USB run using DockPort (USB over DisplayPort).
  • A Thunderbolt device, with the screen driven by DisplayPort over Thunderbolt, and the ethernet card on a PCI/Thunderbolt device (this might be a PCI/Thunderbolt USB controller with a USB ethernet adapter).

There is no way to physically distinguish these cases, maybe there will be some icons, or maybe port colours to act as hints, maybe not. Each of these cases could be supported by the laptop’s operating system, or not.

Leave a Reply